Thursday, April 25th, 2019

Italy’s Italian-first policies are hurting Italians too

“I am an Italian,” said Maurizio Zanga, 62, a laid off garbage collector who lives on the seventh floor next to a family of Somalis.

Maurizio Zanga is among the 30 to 40 per cent of squatters in Rome who are Italian.Credit:Geraldine Ghelli/Washington Post

If Italy’s government offers a test case of what happens when populists come to power, the threat to clear illegally occupied buildings shows how defend-the-country measures can end up hurting citizens too.

Interior Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini – head of the far-right League party – has said all squatted buildings in Rome will be cleared, “none excluded”. The Salvini decree, as his signature policy is known, is a sweeping security measure passed by the government in November and presented as a tool to push back against migration. It also raises penalties for squatters, no matter their nationality or legal status, who can face steeper fines and up to four years’ imprisonment.

Last December, when authorities in Rome cleared a particularly ramshackle building, Salvini showed up at the site and streamed a four-hour video of the operation. He posted on Facebook that the squatters were “mostly migrants”. The video footage included an interview with a man who said he was from the Gambia and would sleep on the street that night.

Italian Deputy Premier and Interior Minister Matteo Salvini is cracking down on immigration.Credit:ANSA/AP

“Send them back to Africa,” one poster wrote below.

“Bravo, Matteo,” another said.

But the prevalence of squatters in Rome speaks not only to a five-year influx of people coming from the Middle East and Africa, but also to a generation-long economic stagnation – and the failure of one government after the next to provide a safety net.

With a dearth of public housing, in a city plagued by economic misfortune and mismanagement, between 10,000 and 11,000 people live as squatters in abandoned factories, office buildings and other properties, according to city data.

Fabrizio Nizi, a housing activist, estimates that 30 to 40 per cent of the squatters in Rome are Italians. Some lost their jobs before retirement age and couldn’t find new positions. Others have struggled to enter the workforce entirely. Some have applied for public housing, but the city faces a logjam, and new units are not being built.

“People wait up to 10 years for a home,” said Nizi. “You need to wait for somebody to die.”

Isaac Olalekan in his bedroom in the former pension building complex in Esquilino, Rome. Credit:Geraldine Ghelli/Washington Post

Rome has not taken an official stance on the squatters, but a city spokesman said that “plenty of the squatted buildings put the safety of their own squatters at risk. The goal is that of offering a dignified alternative.”

Some of the buildings are in dire shape – no windows, trash everywhere. The old pension building, though, more closely resembles a tidy low-income housing complex, albeit one with no heat. The nameplates of old bureaucrats remain posted outside the office rooms. But some of the occupants have decorated their doors with stickers and art. Residents stage theatre performances. Handwritten signs provide rules for a “civil coexistence”. The complex is managed by the residents with help from Action, a housing activist group.

Experts say authorities are unlikely to forcibly clear all squatted buildings, as Salvini has promised. Still, Salvini has managed to raise the anxiety everywhere.

Enrico Mazzarella in his bedroom, a converted office.Credit:Geraldine Ghelli/Washington Post

“Day and night my children are suffering just thinking about it,” said Gianfranco Meneghetti, 53, a resident on the seventh floor of the pension building. Gianfranco was born in Ethiopia but is an Italian citizen. His eldest child, who is 15, sometimes asks what the family would do after eviction. “There is nothing I can say to reassure him,” Meneghetti said.

Pension building residents said Salvini’s threats have also heightened an us-versus-them mentality. People said they notice changes in people on the outside, or even in themselves. Some of the Italian squatters have begun to grumble about the noise and cooking odours made by families from other countries, or about how Ramadan forces changes to building meeting times, or about how foreigners beat them out for low-paying cleaning and caretaking jobs.

Italian squatter Sabina Aristarco has mixed feelings about migration. Credit:Geraldine Ghelli/Washington Post

Sabina Aristarco, 53, an Italian who lives on the first floor, said she’d encountered employers who wanted only people from Africa. “You’d have to be blind not to see the problems with migration,” she said. But, at the same time, she saw the benefits to migration, too. Her closest friends in the building were non-Italian. Her partner was from Tanzania. She saw how people from all over – those fluent in Italian and those just learning – could bicker but then settle disputes at weekly building meetings.

Homeless Italians and migrants camp under the portico of the Roman Catholic Basilica of the Twelve Holy Apostles in downtown Rome in 2017.Credit:AP

At those events, it has been Zanga who often played mediator – stepping into others’ arguments with the gruff and avuncular demeanour of the union boss he once was.

He was established in his career with a waste management company when he was told, in January 2016, that he no longer had a job. He asked his wife and son to go to Colombia, his wife’s home country, where they had family to help them. Zanga tried to stay afloat. Unemployment benefits kicked in, but the payments dwindled month by month until they reached zero. By early 2017, he could no longer pay his rent. By mid-2017, authorities were at his door with an eviction notice. He sold a Sony television for 100 euros to pay for a moving van. Then, with his last possessions – a bed, a robot vacuum cleaner, artwork portraying a Tibetan bridge that he says helps him relax – he showed up on the seventh floor. He told almost none of his family and friends what was happening to him.

“I had a normal life. Books, furniture,” he said, with money to spend to have pizza nights with friends. “Here, I’ve closed myself off.”

Zanga said that falling to the bottom rung has prompted him to gradually reevaluate his views. Until several years ago, he said, he was a “false Democrat”, somebody whose opinions hadn’t yet been tested by hardship. Sometimes, he curses to himself about some of the foreigners living around him, who tend to be younger and have larger, noisier families.

“I have become a bit of a jerk in here. Sometimes I feel like saying, ‘Go back to your own country,’ ” Zanga said. “And then I think to myself, what the f— are you saying?”

But Zanga still doesn’t grasp the goal of clearing out squatters entirely. If he’s kicked out, where would he go? Under a bridge? Another squatted building? For him, there is no country to return to.

“If we were kicked out tomorrow, you still haven’t solved the problem,” Zanga said. “Without a doubt the [government] is reducing the spaces for humanity. Those with a normal social life are inside the fortress. And those who are poor are on the outside.”

The Washington Post